She was rough-cut, a girl of the streets, small but wiry; she’d mouth off to anyone or anything that got in her way. No object was too big for her to tackle; she took no guff from any other living thing.

And yet, she had a tender side, too; albeit one that took a great while to surface. Man or animal, when you have suffered years of untold abuse, it takes a long time and a lot of unconditional love to surmount the hurt. She knew almost immediately when she had transgressed a trust and readily rolled over in submission. Subsequently, she loved to lie on the settee to be idly stroked by whomever sat in contemplative solitude.

Like all of us, she had her bad habits, moments when reason gave way to outright rage; and many a morning solicitor regretted ringing the doorbell or rapping on the front door. Shamelessly, she begged tidbits from the table, dutifully making her rounds until she found the softest heart willing to sneak her a morsel below the cloth.

She loved to be out exploring on an early morning walk; an afternoon saunter by the river was equally pleasant. Her floppy ears, one brown, one white, would bounce in unison as she padded down the street. Intelligent, she would readily sit and offer a forepaw when asked, then wait patiently for a tasty reward.

She played aggressively with stuffed toys, snapping them back and forth in her mouth as if to break their spineless backs; but there was hell to pay for the individual who might attempt to extricate the toy from her teeth.

She adopted any number of stuffed animals as though they were her own offspring, gently cuddling them in her paws, resting her chin on their heads. No human mother was ever more possessive of her children. Jealously, she guarded the bed of any family member she slept with, growling at the approach of another — until it was time for her morning walk and feed.

We did not know what demons possessed her until the very end, when one afternoon without warning she began to pace the kitchen floor in smaller and ever smaller circles, oblivious to her surroundings. She whined and whimpered, pressed her head against the side of her bed, refused to acknowledge our attempts to soothe her discomfort.

A Friday evening wild drive to emergency care resulted in the final diagnosis: some sort of “central neurological event,” most likely a brain tumor.

The palliative care was brief: she didn’t respond to a cocktail of steroids and sedatives; and eighteen hours later we once again returned to the house of healing for her final exit. She died in her mistress’s arms, the young doctor kneeling at her feet, her master looking silently on in untold horror and grief, understanding everything and yet comprehending nothing in the same moment of briefly elapsed time.


Death of a dog

“How long has she been acting like this?” I say, dropping my valise by the corner hutch.

“All afternoon.” My wife pauses momentarily with her knitting. “I don’t think she hears.”

I step over the gate into the kitchen. The little dog continues to pace in circles clockwise, in and out from under the table, always to the right.

I call her name, softly at first, then louder. I clap my hands above her head as she circles; there is no response.

“Did you call the vet?”

“No. I wasn’t sure what to do.”

“Did she go out for a walk today?”

“Just down the street, but she wanted to come home right away. She ate a little bit this morning, but she won’t drink.” The knitting stops. “What should we do?”

I step back over the gate into the dining room and rummage through the stack of papers under the stand for the local telephone directory. I punch in the numbers and wait. Surprisingly, someone picks up on the other end after only two rings. I explain the situation and ask if the vet might be able see the dog.

“We’re all booked up today, tomorrow morning and Monday. The earliest I could get you in would be next Tuesday. I wouldn’t want the dog to wait that long. You could take her to the Veterinary Emergency Center this evening.”

I jot down the number and address. “Thanks for your help,” I say.

Back in the kitchen the dog continues to pace. The circles have gotten tighter and tighter. She approaches her dish in the corner, holds her muzzle above the fresh water, but won’t drink.

I dial the number for the Emergency Center and verify that they are open.

“I suppose we should take her down.”

Immediately, my wife drops her knitting, rises from the chair and reaches for the dog’s leash.

She climbs into the back seat of the SUV, holding the dog swaddled in a towel in her lap. The dog whines and pants. She has never been a good traveler in the car.

It’s a 25-minute ride as I race over winding back-country roads. “Can’t you slow down?” my wife says. “You’re scaring her!”

At last I pull into the small parking area in front of the white clapboard building. Formerly a house, it has been converted into a medical clinic. The front door is partially ajar. A sign on the wall outside says: “Please ring for attendant.” My wife pushes the door open with her foot and steps inside, cradling the swaddled dog in her arms. Across the room an attendant looks up from her desk and greets us with a smile.

“My husband called,” my wife starts to say. Almost immediately another attendant appears from the far door marked “Employees Only” and accepts the dog from my wife. “The doctor will assess the dog in the back,” she says. “We’ll come and get you.”

My wife takes a seat. I stand at the desk and complete the intake form and hand it to the attendant. Soon we are beckoned from the doorway of an exam room opposite. Inside, the dog paces the linoleum tile floor in circles, dragging her twisted leash behind.

The attendant asks us a series of questions: “When did the behavior start? Has the dog been eating? When did she poop last? Was she able to squat? Any recent illnesses? Who is your regular vet? Is the dog up to date on her immunizations?” She records our answers in the computer by the exam table. “The doctor will be in shortly,” she says and steps through the doorway, pulling the door closed behind her.

I sit and watch the dog continue to pace in circles. No amount of coaxing will break her out of it. I think back to our daily walks this past summer. Sometimes she would vomit without warning. Once or twice she collapsed on the ground during these episodes, momentarily losing consciousness. Periodically, her hindquarters would tremble for no apparent reason. Sometimes, as I sat on the front porch, the dog would suddenly start to lick my legs without pause for 20 minutes or more. My wife said she thought the dog craved the salt on my sweaty skin.

The door opens and a young woman appears. She introduces herself as the veterinarian and immediately observes the dog pacing about the room. Shortly, she steps over to the computer and studies the screen with a frown. “When did all of this start?” she asks. Once again, we rehearse our lines. Slowly, she nods her head and taps a few more keys on the keyboard.

The same attendant appears to assist with the examination. The dog resists having her ears looked into. The vet listens with her stethoscope and studies the dog’s eyes. Afterwards, the attendant lifts the dog down from the stainless steel table to the floor. The dog immediately resumes pacing in circles.

“Sometimes we see this behavior with ear infections,” the vet begins, “but there doesn’t seem to be much evidence of that on exam.” She clears her throat. “I’m worried that this behavior is being driven by some sort of neurological problem, probably in the brain.” She pauses a moment, then continues. “I doubt she’s had a stroke — there’s no unusual eye movements, and she’s able to keep her balance — but she could have a tumor in her head. We wouldn’t know that for sure without doing an imaging study. A complete work up would cost somewhere around $1500, and then you’d be looking at treatment options. Frankly, the outlook is not optimal.”

“As far as you can tell, could this be due to some sort of contagious disease. Would we be at risk by keeping her at home?”

“No, this isn’t a contagion. If you don’t feel comfortable taking her home, we could board her here overnight.”

I look over at my wife, who continues to watch the dog pace around the room. “Can you give her anything to calm her down?” she asks.

“We can give her a sedative and some steroids,” the vet says. “That would help get her through the night. You could call us tomorrow with an update. I’ll be here all weekend.”

I nod my head. “Let’s do that.”

Two attendants return with a set of syringes. One attendant lifts the dog back up onto the exam table and restrains her while the other injects the medicines into the dog’s hindquarters. They hand the dog to my wife and usher us out to the front, where I pay the bill.

Back home the dog once again resumes her endless pacing. My wife opens a box of chicken broth and pours some into the dog’s dish. She holds it up to the dog’s nose. Surprisingly, the dog begins to lap the fluid. She drains the bowl, turns her head to the right and immediately resumes her pacing.

Later, I awake in the dark and enter the kitchen to find the dog lying in her small bed, her tiny muzzle resting on the edge. Gently, I place my hand over her head. She opens her eyes, stares straight ahead, then closes them once again. Suddenly, she rises to her feet, steps out of the bed, circles the floor several times, stumbles back into her bed and buries her head in the fluffy lining.

The next morning I call the Emergency Veterinary Center to report the dog’s condition. “I think we need to bring her back in,” I tell the receptionist.

“I’ll let the doctor know you are coming.”

It’s a chore to get the dog into the car. My wife wraps her up in an old towel and climbs into the back seat. I can hear the dog whimpering the entire way down.

There is only one car in the small parking lot when we pull in. Inside, the attendant is waiting. She escorts the two of us into a back office. “The doctor will be in to talk with you shortly,” she says. She looks down at the dog pacing the floor in circles. “Poor thing,” she says, closing the door behind her.

We sit in padded leather chairs, watching the dog pace and pant. I search for the right words. “I don’t think she’s going to get any better,” I say.

“Neither do I,” my wife says. “I don’t want her to be in any more pain.”

Minutes elapse. The dog’s circles become smaller and smaller. Soon the leash is tangled in knots on the floor. Finally, the door opens and the doctor steps into the room. “How did it go last night?” she asks, hunkering down on her haunches to watch the dog.

“Not well. She was up all night, circling on the kitchen floor,” I say. “This morning I saw her pushing her head against the edge of her bed. She seems to be oblivious to both of us.”

“I don’t want her to suffer any more than she has already,” my wife says.

“Yes, I agree,” the doctor says. “These things usually don’t have a good outcome. I’ll have the attendant come to take her in the other room. We’ll give her a sedative to calm her down and put in an IV port. Then we’ll bring her back to you. Would you like to hold her in your lap while we give her the final injection?”

My wife nods. The doctor offers her a tissue from a box on the desk. “She’ll be back shortly,” she says and walks out.

The attendant returns. There are papers to sign, a check to be written. She takes the dog out on the leash. Minutes later she returns with the dog wrapped in a blanket and shifts the bundle to my wife’s arms. The dog’s forepaws are trembling. One foreleg is wrapped with a green elastic dressing. An IV site protrudes from the lower edge.

“I’ll give you a few minutes before the doctor comes in,” the attendant says.

My wife cuddles the dog as though it were a newborn baby. She strokes the fur on her muzzle and whispers into her ear. I stand by the desk, motionless, watching, waiting for the realization of what is happening to sink in.

The door opens and the doctor enters, kneeling down at the foot of my wife’s chair. “She’s heavily sedated,” she says, “not feeling any pain any longer. I’m going to flush the IV port, then administer the medicine.” She reaches into a sleeve on the side of her khaki trousers and withdraws a syringe. The clear fluid flows easily through the IV site. She caps the needle, then withdraws another syringe from an adjacent sleeve. I watch her push the opaque pink fluid into the port. Afterwards, she reaches for the stethoscope around her neck and slips the diaphragm under the dog’s foreleg.

Finally, she says: “She’s gone.”

“I’ll take her to the back and we’ll meet you at your car. Would you like us to remove the collar? You can exit here through the back door privately and walk around.”

Outside, my wife pauses at a flower garden by the walkway while I continue on to the car. The attendant exits the front center door carrying a small cardboard box in her arms. The dog’s collar dangles from her right hand.

I open the rear car door and rest the box on the seat. My wife appears and speaks briefly to the young attendant. I slide in to the driver’s seat while my wife climbs in behind me.

I back the car around and pull out onto the road. “Do you want to go directly home?” I ask, glancing into the rear view mirror.

“Where else would we go?” my wife says.

I shrug my shoulders and drive the rest of the way home in silence.