Full circle

When it comes to systematic medical record keeping, it appears as though we’ve come full circle, as yet another layer has been added to the cost continuum of our healthcare system: the medical scribe.

According to a recent New York Times article, A Busy Doctor’s Right Hand, Ever Ready to Type, the latest trend to surface in medical practice is employing technical scribes to enter salient data into the electronic medical record in real-time, allowing clinicians to maintain eye contact as they talk to their patients.

Dr. Michael Murphy, the chief executive of ScribeAmerica, a company based in Aventura, Fla., that supplies scribes to hospitals and medical practices, estimates that there are nearly 10,000 scribes working in hospitals and medical practices around the country, with demand rising quickly. At his company alone, the number of scribes deployed to clinics and emergency departments has risen to 3,500 from 1,000 in the past three years.

When I first started clinical practice 35 years ago, I learned how to talk to patients. Not only did I talk to them, I spoke with them and I looked at them when I was doing so. I learned to read facial expressions and body language behind their remarks. I learned to look for incongruities that told me something was amiss. Much of what I gleaned during patient interviews held me in good stead when it came time to formulate diagnoses. (Statistics show that after they’ve completed taking the medical history, 85  percent of the time seasoned clinicians have a fairly clear idea of what the diagnosis is before performing the physical examination.)

All of that changed with the advent and subsequent widespread adoption of the electronic medical record (EMR). Clinicians who elect to participate in EMR systems are forced to carry an electronic tablet, notebook or laptop with them from room to room to record the salient points of the medical encounter. But it takes time to enter this myriad data, often at the expense of meaningful human interaction with the patient during the visit.

Advocates of EMR point to the benefits of immediate and shared data retrieval as well as fewer medical errors. Yet anyone who has slugged their way through a day of recording such data understands what a tremendous burden it puts on both clinician and patient alike.

Of course, the bottom line in capturing these myriad extraneous data is that encounters can be billed at a higher level of service. This means more money in the clinician’s pocket and less in the coffers of the third-party payers.

One glitch yet to be rectified is the damper that the EMR places on the numbers of patients seen. Obviously, a clinician can’t work his way through as many patient encounters if he is forced to take the time to record all of the necessary data on the spot. As a result, many clinicians end up taking electronic charts home with them to complete in the late evening hours.

Now we are witnessing the advent of EMR scribes, trained to input data into the electronic medical record in real-time as they follow individual clinicians from one patient encounter to the next. Ironically, this allows clinicians to focus on patients as human beings, maintaining eye contact as they talk with and listen to them. At the same time it allows visits to be billed at a higher level of service; and at the end of the day, no one has to take any additional work home.

One might question the need for yet another person in the exam room. Although her presence clearly benefits the clinician, one wonders what impact it might have on the interaction between the clinician and patient. In addition, in this era of cost containment, one might question the additional fees to pay for the services of scribes.

As a practicing clinician, I never claimed to be able to predict the future; but this time round from where I’m sitting, I think I can read the handwriting on the wall.

Learning to ingest the less than palatable

At some point in my formative years, having been brought up on traditional Pennsylvania Dutch cuisine, I was introduced to pudding. As I recall, I didn’t care much for the texture or the taste.

I quickly learned that to ingest pudding, you had to add a generous coating of pungent mustard and a saltine cracker to make it semi-palatable. To this day I do not seek it out, preferring ring bologna or souse instead.

These days I am fully grown. Far from being force fed, I can comfortably pick and choose those substances that I care to ingest — for the most part.

Which brings me to the electronic medical record, a concoction which I am forced to swallow and digest daily. more»

Interested readers can examine my thoughts on this issue in my latest Musings blog post newly published in the Journal of the American Academy of Physician Assistants.

An assessment of digital diagnoses

When it comes to charting in the medical record, nobody writes SOAP notes anymore. In fact, faced with the EHR format, very few clinicians take the time to type a short narrative. Instead, the available boxes are checked, the Next buttons are hit, the ICD codes are entered, and voila! — the health record is virtually complete!

The only thing missing is a precise description of the condition of the suffering patient. more»

“Medicine in the time of the EMR” posted in YJHM

The EMR, we are told, will help cut healthcare costs.  When medical records are converted into digital format, data will be instantaneously available to all providers caring for the patient.  Clinicians will have carte blanche access to previous laboratory and radiological studies, thus insuring that such investigations are not performed repeatedly or needlessly.  Data will be collated and scrutinized to insure that standards of care are met and that medical errors are eliminated.  Electronic billing will become the norm.  One day patients might even be able to schedule their own appointments online.  Somehow all this will serve to lower costs and improve the efficiency and quality of healthcare delivery.

Indeed it might.  But in my mind healthcare delivery is something different than the practice of medicine….>>more

My latest essay, Medicine in the time of the EMR, is now posted at the Yale Journal for Humanities in Medicine blog, a companion blog for the Yale Journal for Humanities in Medicine.